A CICERONIAN LAWYER'S (RETIRED) MUSINGS ON LAW, PHILOSOPHY, CURRENT AFFAIRS, LITERATURE, HISTORY AND LIVING LIFE SECUNDUM NATURAM
Thursday, November 10, 2022
Living in Cloud Cuckoo Land
Thursday, November 3, 2022
The Only Thing That Will Make You See Sense
Was Mott the Hoople right when it sang all too long ago that Violence is the only thing that will make us see sense? Yes, I mean Violence with a capital "V." If it is, it's likely that it will only make us see sense in the short term, but that may suffice to resuscitate our dwindling civilization until the next time it's required to jolt us into remediative action. Our history repeats itself in certain respects. Think of the statement heard in movies featuring the Mafia, that a war is good for business now and then. Human society may not be significantly different from that of organized crime. Fascists were destroyed in the Second World War but arise once more, in Europe and even here. Read Sinclair Lewis; read George Orwell.
We've had many wars, but the war being spoken of by some now is war of a particular kind. Political war within a political unit; that is to say, a civil war. We've flirted with the idea of one lately, it seems. It may be that the thought of a civil war pleases some of us. Those it pleases most are probably lovers of fantasies in which they figure heroically, brandishing weapons in defense of whatever they find important.
We had a real civil war during the 1860s, of course, but our capacity to forget is such that it's more or less a romantic memory now, even another fantasy, perhaps. Some of us dress up and pretend to be soldiers in that war (and other wars as well, unfortunately). One of the memories of that war we should hold is that it was remarkably bloody; another is that we fight our best (that is to say, do the most harm) when we fight among ourselves. And it seems clear to me, at least, that we're eager to fight among ourselves once more.
The internal war we may face is different from that civil war, though. No great casus belli is available. What causes there are seem mean, petty things taken in themselves--whether we think of sex the same way, or certain people the same way, or agree that certain books shouldn't be read, certain things shouldn't be said, or certain people shouldn't be here or whose love for our Great Republic is seemingly inadequate, or certain religions shouldn't be allowed or followed. Most important, though, is the fear that others may have what we have or take what we have, especially if those others are different than we are.
I suspect that if there is such a war it will be more similar to the internal wars of the French Revolution. There's a kind of regime running this country, a regime born of and sustained by money. Those who have the money despise or are at best indifferent to those who don't, and take great pains to appear as though they have the interests of those they despise or are indifferent to in mind when those of the regime act to foster their own interests. Why it's thought that the regime seeks to benefit anyone but its own members is beyond me. It should be obvious it does not, but suckers must indeed be born every minute.
Still, I can't help but feel that this enchantment will wear off, eventually. And when it does, mere anarchy will be loosed upon the world in a way far more real than the aristocratic Yeats thought it had been all those years ago. Every normal person will not only want to hoist the black flag and start cutting throats (some already do, I think) but will begin the work of slashing. If the kind of hate we see displayed in our society is any indication, many long for a new guillontine already, and there are wannabe Marats and Robespierres standing ready.
There's only so much hypocrisy, venality, sanctimony, arrogance, fraud and contempt one can take. Some day, someone or many someones will notice that things don't change, no matter what is said or done by those with power. They don't change because those in power won't gain, but will rather lose, if change takes place. What will the reaction be when we realize, collectively, that we've been bamboozled?
Monday, October 31, 2022
Of Fantasies and Fantasists
Above is an image from the 1963 film Jason and the Argonauts. I don't know if I saw the film when it was first released, but was a preteen, at least, when I first saw it, at a drive-in theater, I think. I was quite impressed by the fighting skeletons, and the appearance of the gods in various parts of the movie. Poseidon was there, as I recall, standing in a pool of water pushing what I assume were fiberglass cliffs apart to allow Jason's boat passage. There must have been others. I think there was a hydra. I can't remember if the Furies were involved or not. They were in some movie I saw back then, in any case. I enjoyed these garish displays.
Curiously, fighting skeletons figure in our fantasies once again. Entire armies of them in various states of decay appear now and then in Game of Thrones. There must be something about them we find attractive.
I can understand how a preteen and even a teen might enjoy fantasy films along the lines of Jason and the Argonauts. I find it more difficult to understand why an adult would, but it would appear they did, and do. They would have to, in order for such films to make money. Of course, adults may have been and may still be required to attend fantasy movies with children, like those churned out relentlessly by Disney, but it isn't clear to me that they would enjoy doing so. I saw quite a few of those myself when my daughters were young.
I may be wrong, but it strikes me that young and old now are consumed by fantasy, far more than they have been in the past. Games and all forms of media are devoted to it. I have no figures on which to base a comparison, but my guess is that there are far more fantasy stories, games, films, TV, books than there are history, or biography, or documentary non-fiction or historical fiction, and even science fiction. Perfectly respectable and able writers of science fiction such as George R.R. Martin and C.J. Cherryh have lept into fantasy as a genre, creating wizards, mages, dragons, knights, quests of all sorts to entrance us. It's like the second coming of Sir Thomas Malory. This isn't even to mention the vast mound of fantasy erected by J.K Rowling and others, or comic book fantasy like that involving X Men, or Captain America, or Superman, Batman and assorted other super or supra men and women which permeate popular entertainment.
Has this always been the case? I doubt it. I suspect it's more a phenomenon that arose in the 20th century, when the written word and film became more readily available to us all. Technology makes media omnipresent and even more available now. Magazines, comic books, novels, TV and movies were all available in the 20th century, but now are almost obsolete as computers, laptops, tablets and smartphones provide access to everything to everyone.
Fantasy and magic were common in the ancient world but were common because what was thought to be real included them as part of our lives. Gods were everywhere, as were stories involving them, and divination and magic, sometimes by or of the gods and sometimes of demons or those men and women who knew how to invoke their power. Even those philosophers who doubted the common myths involving the gods took them seriously, recognizing that they were real and powerful to most others. They had a profound practical impact on daily life.
That's not the case now, however. Now our reality, our lives, are godless, without magic, without heroes. We can't believe in them, or are in any case wary of appearing to believe in them as part of our day-to-day lives. But we want them to be or at least wish they were. We may even hope or possibly believe they can be, if only....something. The world, as we know it to be, is not enough.
So our dreams and imaginations are populated with them. They're everywhere but "here." And they mean more than anything else because we can't accept their absence. But though there may have been a time when the supernatural or fantasy figures which were made part of religion after the fall of paganism, and which incorporated much of the pagan, sufficed to allow us to tolerate the real, that time seems to be gone. We're more likely to believe fantasy than religion, however fanciful that religion may be.
Monday, October 24, 2022
The Quality of Mercilessness
Wednesday, October 12, 2022
Doomed to Repeat
The insight, or at least the statement, that those who don't know history are doomed to repeat it (with some variation in words used), has been attributed to several figures of note in our history. George Santayana, Winston Churchill and Edmund Burke are some of those who are said to have made this claim. The statement implies that those who know history aren't doomed to repeat it. That may be true, but it remains the case that they may repeat history or are even likely to do so; they're just not doomed to do so.
The fact is that we repeat ourselves, in more ways than one. Repetition is a constant in our affairs. Repetition is even said to be useful in some respects. It may strengthen memory or memorization, for example. It may in ways not entirely clear to me guide us to concentrate in meditation, as in the use of a mantra, which in turn in ways not entirely clear to me may guide us to wisdom or enlightenment. On the other hand, it may bore or annoy us. But we do it. As I've said (though not yet repeatedly).
But the claim, I believe, promises too much if only by implication, and is in that sense misleading. Merely knowing history does very little for us. History may be taught each minute of the day in schools of all sorts and we may even remember the history we're taught, but knowledge of history doesn't necessarily translate to knowledge of human nature, or provide lessons in how to conduct ourselves now and later, unless we're also taught to think.
We're not taught to think, particularly in elementary and high schools as they're called here in our Great Republic. Perhaps it's more accurate to claim that those who don't know how to think are doomed to repeat history.
For example, the danger posed by demagogues, and the tricks employed by them to sway people and even to commit violence, has been known and been the subject of study since the 5th century B.C.E., and perhaps even earlier. We know of Cleon, Alcibiades, Publius Clodius Pulcher from ancient times, religious rabble-rousers from medieval times, the fanatics of the French Revolution like Marat, and of course more recently Mussolini, Hitler, McCarthy and Huey Long, and demagogues are rife in our current politics. Most of us know at least some of the members of this rogues gallery, and at least some of what they did, and it makes no significant difference to their--repetition. Demagogues abide.
I think of the demagogue as an example of our propensity to repeat history because it's that time of year in our Glorious Union when politicians vie for our favor in what we're pleased to call elections. Perhaps there are parts of the country where TV, the Internet, and all other forms of media are not crowded with political appeals, but in the place where I reside those appeals are ceaseless, and omnipresent. And there can be no better examples of demagoguery than these appeals. Sanctimony, fear-mongering, pandering, polarizing tactics, misrepresentations, evasiveness, lying, appeals to emotion, authority and bigotry...all of the usual characteristics of this practice are present in abundance. The appeals are incessant.
It's at least possible, and more likely probable, that those bombarded by this treacle, by these disingenuous if not outright dishonest commercials made by and for glorified carnival barkers, are aware of demagogues of the past and may even think them despicable. But their ubiquity indicates that they're effective (they cost money, and money is most important), and if they're effective that indicates that our knowledge of history be damned, were doomed to repeat it.
I tend to agree with John Dewey's insight that we only think when confronted with problems. Otherwise, we act based largely on habits accrued over a lifetime. But we must believe a problem exists before we have recourse to thought, i.e. the use and application of intelligence.
We don't believe repeating the mistakes of the past is a problem, unfortunately. Perhaps we believe we're doomed to repeat the past no matter how much we're aware of it.
We know history or don't, AND are doomed to repeat it regardless.

.png)
_Children_of_the_night_2.png)

.png)